Why Scientists Are Sure Planet Kepler-10b Is Rocky
SEATTLE — When astronomers announced Jan. 10 the discovery of Kepler-10b, they described the alien world as “unquestionably rocky.”
Scientists have announced other rocky exoplanets in the past, but Kepler-10b earns its title, researchers said, because they are sure of its composition. And that is because they know its host star so well. In fact, the Kepler-10 star is one of the most well-characterized planet-hosting stars in the universe.
Once researchers first picked up Kepler-10b’s signal, back in 2009, they trained the Kepler Space Telescope on its parent star, located about 560 light years from Earth. Scientists took extremely detailed measurements of the star’s brightness oscillations, using this information to probe its interior, in much the same way that geologists use earthquakes to study Earth’s interior.
This method, called asteroseismology, allows researchers to learn a great deal about a star’s structure, including its size. Once the scientists had this information in hand, they used it to deduce the size and density of Kepler-10b.
Researchers now know the properties of the parent star within 2 to 6 percent, Natalie Batalha, leader of the study announcing the new planet’s discovery, told reporters here Jan. 10 at the winter meeting of the American Astronomical Society.
“We know what this star is,” Batalha said.
Figuring out Kepler-10b’s density
Batalha and her colleagues made their discovery using NASA’s Kepler space telescope, whose primary mission is to hunt down potentially habitable Earth-like planets in our galaxy. Kepler finds alien planets that pass in front of their host stars, picking up on the tiny brightness dips that occur when such “transits” take place.
The magnitude of those brightness dips — in Kepler-10b’s case, it was a drop of 0.015 percent, Batalha said — tells researchers how big the planet is, relative to its parent star.
Measurements made by the W.M. Keck Observatory in Hawaii determined how much the newly discovered planet tugged on its star, making it wobble. These observations yielded the planet’s mass — again, relative to the parent star.
If a planet’s mass and volume are known, it is a simple step to calculate its density, which tells researchers the likely composition. But to do this for the hellishly hot Kepler-10b, Batalha and her colleagues needed to convert relative mass and density into absolutes.
And that is where Kepler’s asteroseismology observations came in. Since the team got such a detailed and accurate look at the star, they feel confident that they are getting Kepler-10b’s density correct. The researchers calculated the density of Kepler-10b at 8.8 grams per cubic centimeter, which places it squarely in the “rocky” category, just like Earth.
“Kepler-10b is the smallest exoplanet discovered to date, and the first unquestionably rocky planet orbiting a star outside our solar system,” Batalha said. “The composition could even be consistent with an Earth composition.”
What about Corot-7b?
Kepler-10b is not the first exoplanet scientists have claimed is rocky. In 2009, for example, a different research team announced that the smallish, scorched alien world Corot-7b is rocky as well.
When asked about Corot-7b, Batalha did not claim that it was not rocky. But she did say that there is enough uncertainty in the measurements to leave some doubt — hence Kepler-10b’s status as the first “unquestionably rocky” alien planet ever found.
“Corot-7b was indeed a very important discovery,” Batalha said. It could turn out to be rocky, she added, but it is difficult to say for sure at the moment. “It’s a tough one.”