Sustained Budget Key to Manned Mars Missions, Experts Say
NEW YORK — Sending humans to Mars by the 2030s is affordable, a group of experts finds, but some key changes are needed if it is going to happen.
A workshop group of more than 60 individuals representing more than 30 government, industry, academic and other organizations has found that a NASA-led manned mission to Mars is feasible if the space agency’s budget is restored to presequestration levels. Putting the first humans on the red planet would also require international cooperation and private industry support.
There is a growing consensus in the space community that a manned mission to Mars should be a priority worth working toward in the coming years, according to Chris Carberry, executive director of Explore Mars Inc., the organization that hosted the workshop with the American Astronautical Society.
“To be able to make it feasible and affordable, you need a sustainable budget,” Carberry said. “You need a budget that is consistent, that you can predict from year to year and that doesn’t get canceled in the next administration.”
While Carberry said that it is possible to launch a manned mission to Mars by the 2030s under presequestration budget levels, a NASA-led human mission to Mars will probably never launch under current budgetary constraints, he said.
“We’re not far off from what we need,” Carberry said. “We just need to get back into a reasonable budget, which we’re not in right now.”
President Barack Obama requested about $17.7 billion for NASA in his 2013 budget proposal, $59 million less than what the space agency received in 2012.
“[NASA] funds are divided between various missions, directorates and centers,” Carberry said via email. “Unless there was a MAJOR restructuring, it would be hard to accomplish a NASA-led Mars mission [under the current budget]. That said, major disruptive technology gains could always occur that could make it viable — we just can’t count on that happening.”
The workshop group’s plan hinges partially upon the availability of NASA’s heavy-lift rocket, the Space Launch System (), and the space agency’s deep-space crew capsule, the Orion spacecraft. SLS and Orion are both in development now, with Orion’s first unmanned test flight slated for later this year.
In December 2013, attendees affiliated with NASA, Boeing, Orbital Sciences Corp. and many others at the Affording Mars Workshop arrived at six agreements that could frame the way that space agencies work toward a manned mission to Mars.
- The goal of sending humans to Mars is affordable with the right partnerships (international, commercial/industrial, intergovernmental, etc.), commitment to efficiency, constancy of purpose and policy/budget consistency.
- Human exploration of Mars is technologically feasible by the 2030s.
- Mars should be the priority for human spaceflight for the next two to three decades.
- Between now and 2030, investments and activities in the human exploration of space must be prioritized in a manner that advances the objective of initial human missions to Mars beginning in the 2030s.
- Utilizing the international space station, including international partnerships, is essential for human missions to deep space.
- Continuation of robotic precursor missions to Mars throughout the 2020s is essential for the success of human missions to Mars.
Carberry said that the experts are still not sure whether a long or short mission to the red planet would be best when launching the first manned mission to Mars.
Getting to Mars
As a model of international collaboration and a huge undertaking in space, the international space station could provide vital lessons about getting humans to Mars, Carberry said. The space station mission is the best example of a consistent budget set forth for a huge project in space, he added.
“The only reason [the international space station] has survived the years is because it’s an international mission,” Carberry said. “It is held together by international treaties and strong agreements. … If we were to follow that model and maybe even move on with the partnership to the next step, that perhaps could be the greatest legacy of ISS because that’s a proven model of sustainability, because you have more holding it together than just that annual cycle.”
The $100 billion orbiting outpost could also be used to mimic parts of a mission to the red planet. Engineers could use the orbiting laboratory to demonstrate telerobotics and new spacesuits, and to work out possible problems that could arise on a trip to Mars.
The workshop group also explored the idea of a mission that would bridge the space station and a manned mission to Mars. Agencies should consider such a bridge mission when moving forward toward a launch date in the 2030s, the workshop found.
The bridge mission could be anything from NASA’s ambitious plan to capture an asteroid and bring it into lunar orbit where astronauts could explore it, to a small and temporary station where astronauts can learn a little more about fending for themselves while in space.
“When they’re on ISS, they communicate [with Earth] every day — they can barely do anything without communicating with Mission Control,” Carberry said. “They need to get out of the habit of that, and they know that.”